NEW REPORT

THE 2026 BFCM PROFIT: The Lessons Hidden in Last Year's Data

Get the report

THE 2026 BFCM PROFIT REPORT

The Lessons Hidden in Last Year's Data

The fragmentation of commerce: why infrastructure wins the next decade

The fragmentation of commerce: why infrastructure wins the next decade

The fragmentation of commerce: why infrastructure wins the next decade

Carla Penn-Kahn

CEO and Co-founder of ProfitPeak

Copy URL

Checkout is leaving the storefront. Customers now buy inside TikTok, Instagram, marketplaces and, increasingly, AI assistants. Each new channel adds revenue. Each one also strips away some of the data a brand needs to understand who bought and why.

That trade-off is the defining challenge of multi-channel commerce. The brands that handle it well won’t be the ones that pick the right channel. They’ll be the ones with the infrastructure to make sense of every channel at once.

The short answer: Commerce doesn’t consolidate. It fragments, then expands. Infrastructure that connects orders, customers, inventory and margin across every channel is what lets a brand keep growing without losing sight of its own business.

What is the blind order problem?

When a customer buys inside a social or marketplace checkout, the order can reach Shopify with little or no customer identity attached. The brand records a sale but often can’t tell who made it.

That gap has real consequences. Without a customer record, a brand can’t follow up, can’t attribute the sale properly and can’t build a relationship with the person who bought. Revenue goes up. Customer intelligence doesn’t.

TikTok Shop made the problem visible. As more platforms build their own checkout, more orders will arrive this way, and at greater scale.

Why does checkout moving off-site matter?

Discovery and purchase are collapsing into the same moment. A customer sees a product in a feed and buys it without ever visiting the brand’s site.

That isn’t bad news. It removes friction and opens up new demand. But it creates a structural data gap. Brands that can reconcile off-site orders with their own customer, product and margin data will grow intelligently. Brands that can’t will be scaling revenue they don’t fully understand.

Is channel fragmentation a threat or an opportunity?

Every major shift in commerce has been called the end of something. Ecommerce was meant to kill the high street. It forced omnichannel instead. Mobile was meant to end desktop. It forced mobile-first design. Social discovery didn’t replace search. It added a new layer on top.

The pattern holds. Each new channel is additive. Very few brands are pure-play online anymore. Most already sell through at least one marketplace, social shop, wholesale partner or physical store. AI assistants and agentic commerce are the next additions, not replacements.

The brands that win show up wherever their customer is, and understand every interaction in one place.

What does commerce infrastructure need to do?

Marketing measurement still matters. Attribution, ROAS and incrementality all have a place. On their own, they’re no longer enough. Winning in a fragmented market takes infrastructure that does four jobs.

1. Connect every order to a customer

Whether an order comes from a marketplace, a social checkout, a wholesale partner or an AI agent, it needs to link back to a known customer wherever possible. Revenue without customer context builds sales, not a business.

2. Keep inventory live

When customers and agents buy across several channels at once, stock data that’s a day old is a liability. Every channel needs to sell from the same, current view of what’s actually available.

3. Keep product data clean and structured

AI assistants, marketplaces and ad platforms all rely on structured product data to surface the right product at the right moment. Inconsistent product information makes a brand harder to find in the channels growing fastest.

4. Keep margin visible in real time

As more of commerce becomes automated, the financial picture has to keep pace. Margin and contribution profit by product and channel can’t lag days behind the transactions.


Which brands will win the next decade?

The question isn’t which channel wins. Every channel will take a share. The question is which brands can see their whole business clearly as it spreads across those channels.

That clarity is the advantage. It decides where ad spend goes, which products get reordered and which customers get brought back. Brands without it will keep adding channels and keep losing visibility with each one.

That is the context Sherpa, ProfitPeak’s AI agent, works from. It monitors your live business data from ads to warehouse in one shared view. When stock ages, a size runs out or ad spend goes to a product you can’t ship, it drafts the move, applies your brand’s rules, and you sign off in one tap.

Operate at your peak

ProfitPeak brings your business together in one shared view, from advertising to inventory, with AI that spots the next move and helps your team act on it.