What is the discount break-even formula?
Revenue, orders, conversion rate and ROAS show how customers respond to a promotion. They do not show what the promotion contributes to the business. That takes contribution profit.
Required increase in units sold = Discount % ÷ (Gross margin % − Discount %)
Take a product that sells for $100 at a 50% gross margin. Each full-price sale earns $50 in gross profit. At 20% off, the price drops to $80. With cost of goods unchanged at $50, each sale now earns $30.
To earn the same $50, you need to sell 1.67 units for every unit you would have sold at full price. That is a 67% increase in unit sales just to break even on gross profit, for a promotion offering 20% off.
These are gross-profit break-even figures. They assume the discount comes off the original selling price and cost of goods per unit stays the same. Once fulfilment, payment fees, expected returns and advertising are included, the hurdle is higher.
Maintaining revenue and maintaining profit are different targets. 20% off needs 25% more units to hold revenue flat. At a 50% gross margin, it needs 67% more units to hold gross profit flat.
Plan a promotion on revenue targets alone and you will underestimate the demand you need.
Why can a successful sale still be unprofitable?
Revenue, orders, conversion rate and ROAS show how customers respond to a promotion. They do not show what the promotion contributes to the business. That takes contribution profit.
Contribution profit is the revenue left after product costs and the variable costs of generating and fulfilling each order.
Depending on how your business measures it, that includes fulfilment, payment processing, expected returns and advertising. Discounts belong in the revenue line. If you use net sales after discounts, do not subtract the discount a second time.
The Sugar High data shows why this matters. In that Australian sample, brands running 11 or more discount events a year saw profit margins fall 11% year on year. Brands running five or fewer saw margins improve 8%. That is a 19-percentage-point gap.
Discount frequency alone does not explain the whole gap. Product mix, brand strength, pricing and acquisition costs all affect profitability. But the pattern is strong enough to question how often brands rely on promotions to create demand.
Do discounts reach new customers or existing ones?
A promotion assumes lower prices create sales that would not otherwise happen. Sometimes they do. A sale can also prompt existing customers to buy earlier, or hand a discount to someone happy to pay full price.
The same research found 88% of orders during promotional periods were discounted. Returning customers placed 68% of those discounted orders. At full price, returning customers made up just 11% of orders.
A returning customer buying at a discount is not a bad outcome in itself. Repeat customers are valuable, and a deliberate promotion can strengthen the relationship. The point is to separate genuinely additional demand from sales that would have happened anyway. Otherwise a campaign can look like an acquisition win while giving margin to people already planning to buy.
Before your next promotion, review the customers from your last sale: the share who were new, the share who had recently bought at full price, and how their buying changed afterwards. That shows whether the discount created new value or only changed when, and at what price, customers bought.
4 costs that hit your profit after a promotion ends
A promotion keeps costing you after the sale ends, in four main ways.
1. Customers bring purchases forward
When a discount is available today, some customers buy now instead of next month. The sale period looks stronger, but part of that demand is borrowed from the weeks ahead.
In the same research, revenue fell an average of 27% below its normal baseline in the two to four weeks after a promotional event. Not every dollar of that drop comes from early buying. Seasonality and campaign timing play a part. But the pattern belongs in any evaluation of promotion performance. A strong sale week reads differently when several weaker weeks of full-price trading follow it.
2. Discount-acquired customers can be worth less over time
A compelling offer makes acquisition easy during a major event. Bringing those customers back without another discount is harder.
Across Ometria's retail clients, just 4% of customers acquired during Black Friday 2024 made a repeat purchase within 12 months (Ometria). Earlier research by Michael Lewis in the Journal of Marketing Research (2006) found the same direction: in the datasets studied, customers acquired with a 35% discount had about half the long-term value of customers acquired without a promotion.
These findings come from different customer populations and are not universal benchmarks. They do show that a new customer's value is not set by their first order. Judge a promotion on repeat purchasing, later order profitability and customer value over time, not acquisition volume alone.
3. Returns arrive after the revenue is recorded
Returns weigh heavily on promotional profitability, especially in categories where sizing and fit lead customers to order several options. The National Retail Federation estimated 19.3% of US online sales would be returned in 2025 (NRF). That is not a Black Friday-specific rate, but it shows why returns belong in promotional forecasts.
A returned order reverses the revenue and can leave advertising, payment, shipping and handling costs behind. Build expected return rates into your contribution profit forecast instead of waiting for the returns to arrive.
4. Advertising costs rise when everyone competes for attention
During Black Friday, thousands of brands compete for the same customers at once. Lebesgue found the median brand in its sample paid 59% more per thousand Meta impressions in Black Friday week 2025 than in September (Lebesgue).
Higher CPMs do not automatically make advertising unprofitable. Conversion often improves during high-intent periods. But they make the margin on promoted products even more important. You can end up paying more to reach customers while earning less on each product sold, and a healthy ROAS will not show it.
6 steps to plan a discount that protects your profit
Planning a profitable discount comes down to six steps.
1. Start with product-level profitability
Before choosing a discount, know the economics of each product you might promote: selling price, cost of goods, fulfilment, payment fees, expected returns and the advertising needed to generate a sale. You need to know how much contribution each product holds before giving any of it away.
2. Calculate the sales lift you need
Use the break-even formula to estimate the extra units the proposed discount requires. For a more accurate contribution profit figure, separate the costs that move with selling price from those fixed per order. Keep advertising and campaign costs explicit instead of assuming they stay flat. If a discount needs a 70% lift in unit sales just to hold profit, you need strong evidence that demand exists.
3. Compare it with previous promotions
Check how similar products performed in past sales. Look at whether the discount generated enough extra units to cover the margin given away, and whether the lift was spread across products or concentrated in items that already sold well. Past performance is no guarantee, but it is a useful reality check on an ambitious target.
4. Understand who is likely to buy
Customer mix can change a promotion's economics entirely. Look at the split of discounted purchases between new and returning customers, how often those customers buy at full price, and how earlier promotional cohorts performed over time. This tells you whether an offer should go to everyone or to a specific audience.
5. Plan for what happens after the sale
Build the weeks after the promotion into your forecast. Account for pulled-forward demand, realistic post-sale revenue, and the returns and fulfilment costs still to come. Evaluate a promotion over a commercially meaningful period, not just the days the sale banner is live.
6. Protect the products that do not need a discount
If a product already sells consistently at full price with healthy margins and strong demand, discounting it has little upside. Ageing products with weak demand may suit a targeted promotion, provided the price still meets your commercial objective. The best strategy is rarely the biggest discount. It is better decisions about where a discount is genuinely needed.
Make the decision before the sale, not after it
The most successful promotion is not the one with the most orders or the highest revenue. It is the one that delivers the commercial outcome you planned: valuable new customers, cleared ageing inventory or profitable incremental sales.
The Sugar High findings make a clear case for planning discounts more carefully. When 70% of discount events in that sample failed to generate positive contribution profit, brands have room to be far more selective about where they give margin away. That starts with understanding your products, your customers and the real cost behind every sale.
That is the context Sherpa, ProfitPeak’s AI agent, works from. It monitors your live business data from ads to warehouse. When stock ages or a size runs out, it drafts the markdown, campaign or budget change, applies your brand’s rules, and you sign off in one tap.







