NEW REPORT

THE 2026 BFCM PROFIT: The Lessons Hidden in Last Year's Data

Get the report

THE 2026 BFCM PROFIT REPORT

The Lessons Hidden in Last Year's Data

The inventory decisions that cost fashion brands the most margin

The inventory decisions that cost fashion brands the most margin

The inventory decisions that cost fashion brands the most margin

ProfitPeak team

Copy URL

Fashion inventory is unforgiving. Trends move in weeks, seasons end on a fixed date, and mistakes compound fast.

Working with fashion retailers, one pattern stands out. The brands losing the most margin rarely lose it on the shop floor. They lose it months earlier, in the buying decisions that set what gets ordered, when and how much.

The short answer: The five inventory decisions that cost fashion brands the most margin are over-ordering, buying too broadly, poor size and colour profiling, emergency reorders and delayed markdowns. Each one is fixed by acting on current sell-through data at SKU level, on a weekly cycle.

Why does over-ordering cost more than a stockout?

Avoiding a stockout feels safe. Over-buying is usually the more expensive mistake.

Excess stock doesn’t sit quietly. It ties up cash and warehouse space, then gets cleared at deep markdowns that wipe out the margin it was bought to earn.

Many brands still set open-to-buy budgets with last year’s performance as the main input. That misses shifting demand, new competitors and changing customer behaviour.


Our recommendation:

Replace history-only forecasting with a model that layers in current sell-through and forward demand signals, so open-to-buy reflects where the market is heading.


How does buying too broadly hurt margin?

Chasing trend coverage spreads the buy too thin. Teams add dozens of new styles each season in small quantities instead of going deep on proven performers.

The result is a range full of styles that never sell fast enough to be profitable, while the best sellers run out early.

Brands that concentrate open-to-buy on a tighter range, backed by data on what actually sells, tend to protect more margin than brands chasing newness for its own sake.


Our recommendation:

Use style-level data from prior seasons to identify your top-quartile performers, and buy depth in those before funding new introductions.


How does size and colour profiling affect margin?

Size and colour ratios are where a lot of margin quietly disappears. A style can sell most of its units and still go to markdown, because what’s left is all XS, or in a colour nobody wants. The sell-through looks like a success. The discount says otherwise.

Getting ratios right takes SKU-level sales analysis, not category averages.


Our recommendation:

Build size and colour curves at SKU level, segmented by store or channel, and review them every season instead of carrying old assumptions forward.


Why do emergency reorders erode margin?

When a style takes off unexpectedly, the pressure to chase it is real. Reorders placed outside the planned production window usually carry extra costs: expediting, air freight and supplier surcharges.

What looks like a revenue opportunity can deliver thin or negative margin by the time the units land. The brands that handle this well aren’t faster at reacting. They’re better at anticipating, using early sell-through to reorder while standard production and freight are still available.


Our recommendation:

Set automatic sell-through triggers around the four-week mark, so reorder decisions happen while production slots and standard freight are still open.


What does a delayed markdown cost?

Every week a clearance decision waits costs margin. A garment marked down early in the season recovers more than the same garment marked down late. Yet many brands wait for an end-of-season review before acting.

Brands that make inventory decisions on a weekly cycle hold more margin than brands that review monthly or seasonally.


Our recommendation:

Set a weekly trading rhythm with a standing review of slow movers, and agree markdown triggers by week and weeks of cover in advance, so clearance is systematic, not reactive.

Fix the decisions upstream

None of these mistakes happen at the till. They happen in planning, months earlier, on data that was already out of date.

Sherpa, ProfitPeak’s AI agent, monitors your live business data from ads to warehouse. When stock ages or a size runs out, it drafts the markdown, purchase order or campaign, applies your brand’s rules, and you sign off in one tap.

Operate at your peak

ProfitPeak brings your business together in one shared view, from advertising to inventory, with AI that spots the next move and helps your team act on it.